Dr. Mindy Pelz vs Dr. Jason Fung

Compare Dr. Mindy Pelz's Fasting Reset protocol with Dr. Jason Fung's intermittent fasting approach. Both are leading voices in the fasting movement and agree that insulin is the key driver of metabolic disease — but Pelz differentiates her protocol by tailoring fasting to women's hormonal cycles, incorporating gut-healing foods and adaptogens, while Fung takes a more straightforward clinical approach applicable to all patients. Pelz layers in more supplements; Fung keeps the intervention lean and focused on meal timing.

Side-by-Side Comparison

CategoryDr. Mindy PelzDr. Jason Fung
TitleFasting Expert & Functional Health PractitionerNephrologist & Bestselling Author of The Obesity Code
Focus Areas
fastinghormonesgut healthwomens healthnutritionsupplementsmetabolic health
fastingdiabetesinsulin resistanceweight lossdiet
Total Products1214
Shared Products6 products in common
ProtocolA hormone-aware fasting protocol designed especially for women, combining cyclical fasting lengths with gut-healing foods, fermented vegetables, and targeted supplementation to restore metabolic and hormonal balance.A physician-developed fasting protocol focused on intermittent and extended fasting to lower insulin levels, reverse type 2 diabetes, and promote sustainable weight loss — emphasizing whole foods, natural fasting aids, and minimal supplementation.

What They Agree On

Both Dr. Mindy Pelz and Dr. Jason Fung include these 6 products in their protocols — a signal of strong evidence and broad expert consensus.

Bone Broth

Nutrient-dense broth made by simmering animal bones for extended periods. Rich in collagen, glycine, and minerals. Frequently recommended by Dr. Jason Fung as one of the best fasting aids — it provides electrolytes and a small amount of protein to ease hunger during extended fasts without significantly raising insulin.

🌿

Bone Broth

foods

Apple Cider Vinegar

Raw, unfiltered apple cider vinegar with the 'mother' culture. Research suggests it may help reduce blood sugar spikes after meals by slowing gastric emptying. Dr. Jason Fung recommends it as a fasting aid — a tablespoon or two in water can help suppress hunger and stimulate digestion when breaking a fast.

🌿

Apple Cider Vinegar

foods

Vitamin D3 (5000 IU)

High-potency vitamin D3 supplement providing 5000 IU per serving to support optimal blood levels. Essential for immune function, bone health, and mood regulation. One of the most widely recommended supplements among longevity researchers due to widespread deficiency.

Vitamin D3 (5000 IU)

supplements

Magnesium (Threonate/Glycinate)

Highly bioavailable magnesium in threonate or glycinate form for superior absorption. Supports deep sleep quality, cognitive function, and nervous system relaxation. Magnesium threonate is particularly valued for its ability to cross the blood-brain barrier.

Magnesium (Threonate/Glycinate)

supplements

Omega-3 Fish Oil (High EPA)

High-potency omega-3 fish oil supplement with elevated EPA content. Supports cardiovascular health, reduces systemic inflammation, and promotes healthy brain function and mood regulation.

Omega-3 Fish Oil (High EPA)

supplements

Electrolyte Mix

Balanced electrolyte mix containing sodium, potassium, and magnesium to support hydration and cellular function. Essential for maintaining energy levels, muscle function, and cognitive performance, especially during fasting or exercise. Sugar-free formulas are preferred in longevity protocols.

Electrolyte Mix

supplements

Where They Differ

These products are unique to one protocol — reflecting each expert's distinct philosophy, research focus, and priorities.

Dr. Mindy Pelz

Only in Dr. Mindy Pelz's Protocol

Probiotics (Multi-Strain)

Multi-strain probiotic supplement containing diverse beneficial bacteria to support gut microbiome health. A balanced gut microbiome is linked to improved digestion, immune function, and mental well-being. Look for formulas with clinically studied strains and high CFU counts.

Melatonin (Low Dose)

Low-dose melatonin supplement to support natural circadian rhythm and sleep onset. Research suggests doses of 0.3-1 mg are often more effective than higher amounts for improving sleep quality. Also studied for its antioxidant properties and potential anti-aging benefits.

MCT Oil

Medium-chain triglyceride (MCT) oil is a concentrated fat supplement derived from coconut or palm kernel oil. MCTs are rapidly absorbed and converted to ketones in the liver, providing quick energy for the brain and body. Popular among fasting and keto practitioners for sustaining energy without spiking insulin.

Turmeric / Curcumin

Turmeric extract standardized for curcumin content, a potent anti-inflammatory compound. Supports joint health, reduces chronic inflammation, and may protect against age-related cognitive decline. Best absorbed when paired with piperine (black pepper extract) or in a liposomal formulation.

Fermented Foods (Kimchi, Sauerkraut, Kefir)

Naturally fermented foods rich in live beneficial bacteria to support gut microbiome diversity. Regular consumption of kimchi, sauerkraut, and kefir has been shown to reduce markers of systemic inflammation. A Stanford study found fermented foods increased microbial diversity more effectively than a high-fiber diet.

Ashwagandha (KSM-66)

KSM-66 ashwagandha root extract, the most clinically studied form of this traditional adaptogenic herb. Supports healthy cortisol levels, reduces perceived stress, and may improve sleep quality and exercise recovery. Widely used in longevity protocols for its effects on hormonal balance and resilience to chronic stress.

Dr. Jason Fung

Only in Dr. Jason Fung's Protocol

Black Coffee

High-quality black coffee, one of the most widely recommended beverages during intermittent fasting. Contains caffeine and chlorogenic acid, which may increase metabolic rate and fat oxidation. Dr. Jason Fung considers black coffee an excellent fasting companion — it suppresses appetite, does not stimulate insulin, and may enhance the metabolic benefits of fasting.

Green Tea (Matcha)

High-quality matcha green tea powder rich in EGCG catechins and L-theanine. Provides calm, sustained energy while delivering powerful antioxidant and anti-inflammatory benefits. Regular green tea consumption is associated with reduced cardiovascular disease risk and improved metabolic health in population studies.

Chia Seeds

Organic chia seeds rich in soluble fiber, omega-3 fatty acids, and plant protein. When soaked in liquid they form a filling gel that expands in the stomach. Dr. Jason Fung recommends chia seeds as a fasting variation — their high fiber content helps manage hunger during fasts with minimal insulin stimulation.

Pasture-Raised Eggs

Pasture-raised eggs are a nutrient-dense whole food providing complete protein, healthy fats, choline, and fat-soluble vitamins. Among protein sources, eggs produce one of the lowest insulin responses — making them a preferred choice in Dr. Jason Fung's protocol for meals that support metabolic health and stable blood sugar.

Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Cold-pressed extra virgin olive oil, a cornerstone of Mediterranean and longevity diets. Rich in polyphenols and oleic acid.

Wild-Caught Salmon

Wild-caught salmon is one of the best whole-food sources of omega-3 fatty acids EPA and DHA. Rich in high-quality protein, astaxanthin, and vitamin D, it supports cardiovascular and brain health. Consuming fatty fish 2-3 times per week is a cornerstone recommendation across longevity protocols.

Ceylon Cinnamon

Ceylon cinnamon, known as 'true cinnamon,' is a spice with research-supported blood sugar lowering properties. It may improve insulin sensitivity and help reduce fasting glucose levels. Dr. Jason Fung recommends cinnamon as a natural way to manage hunger during fasts — it adds flavor to beverages without stimulating insulin and may have protective metabolic effects.

Product Comparison

ProductDr. Mindy PelzDr. Jason Fung
Bone BrothRecommendedRecommended
Apple Cider VinegarRecommendedRecommended
Vitamin D3 (5000 IU)RecommendedRecommended
Magnesium (Threonate/Glycinate)RecommendedRecommended
Omega-3 Fish Oil (High EPA)RecommendedRecommended
Electrolyte MixRecommendedRecommended
Probiotics (Multi-Strain)Recommended---
Melatonin (Low Dose)Recommended---
MCT OilRecommended---
Turmeric / CurcuminRecommended---
Fermented Foods (Kimchi, Sauerkraut, Kefir)Recommended---
Black Coffee---Recommended
Green Tea (Matcha)---Recommended
Chia Seeds---Recommended
Pasture-Raised Eggs---Recommended
Extra Virgin Olive Oil---Recommended

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between Dr. Mindy Pelz's and Dr. Jason Fung's protocols?

Compare Dr. Mindy Pelz's Fasting Reset protocol with Dr. Jason Fung's intermittent fasting approach. Both are leading voices in the fasting movement and agree that insulin is the key driver of metabolic disease — but Pelz differentiates her protocol by tailoring fasting to women's hormonal cycles, incorporating gut-healing foods and adaptogens, while Fung takes a more straightforward clinical approach applicable to all patients. Pelz layers in more supplements; Fung keeps the intervention lean and focused on meal timing.

What do Dr. Mindy Pelz and Dr. Jason Fung both recommend?

Both experts recommend Bone Broth, Apple Cider Vinegar, Vitamin D3 (5000 IU), Magnesium (Threonate/Glycinate), Omega-3 Fish Oil (High EPA), Electrolyte Mix. These shared recommendations carry extra weight because they represent consensus across two independent, well-informed approaches to longevity.

Which protocol is better for beginners?

Both protocols can be adapted for beginners. Start with the fundamentals both experts agree on — Bone Broth, Apple Cider Vinegar, Vitamin D3 (5000 IU), Magnesium (Threonate/Glycinate), Omega-3 Fish Oil (High EPA), Electrolyte Mix — then gradually explore the unique elements of each protocol based on your specific health goals and budget.

All Products From Both Protocols

🌿

Bone Broth

foods

🌿

Apple Cider Vinegar

foods

Vitamin D3 (5000 IU)

supplements

Magnesium (Threonate/Glycinate)

supplements

Omega-3 Fish Oil (High EPA)

supplements

Electrolyte Mix

supplements

Probiotics (Multi-Strain)

supplements

Melatonin (Low Dose)

supplements

MCT Oil

supplements

Turmeric / Curcumin

supplements

🌿

Fermented Foods (Kimchi, Sauerkraut, Kefir)

foods

Ashwagandha (KSM-66)

supplements

🌿

Black Coffee

foods

🌿

Green Tea (Matcha)

foods

🌿

Chia Seeds

foods

🌿

Pasture-Raised Eggs

foods

🌿

Extra Virgin Olive Oil

foods

🌿

Wild-Caught Salmon

foods

🌿

Ceylon Cinnamon

foods

Links may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you.

More Comparisons

Get Protocol Comparisons in Your Inbox

New comparisons, product reviews, and the latest longevity research — weekly.

Get our free Longevity Stack Cheat Sheet — what 12 experts actually take.